Status of monument -> National monument
Published
in the “Official Gazette of BiH”, no. 84/09.
Pursuant
to Article V para. 4 Annex 8 of the General Framework Agreement for Peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina
and Article 39 para. 1 of the Rules of Procedure of the Commission to Preserve
National Monuments, at a session held from 12 to 18 May 2009 the Commission
adopted a
D E C I S
I O N
I
The
natural and architectural ensemble of the Orthodox church of the Ascension in
Požarnica with its old oak tree, Municipality Tuzla is
hereby designated as a National Monument of Bosnia and Herzegovina
(hereinafter: the National Monument).
The
National Monument consists of the church of the Ascension, the remains of the
old school building, the burial ground and an old oak tree.
The
National Monument is located on a site designated as cadastral plot nos. 329,
330, 331 and 332 (new survey), municipality Kovačevo Selo, Municipality Tuzla,
Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina,
Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The
provisions relating to protection measures set forth by the Law on the
Implementation of the Decisions of the Commission to Preserve National
Monuments, established pursuant to Annex 8 of the General Framework Agreement
for Peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina (Official Gazette of the Federation of BiH
nos. 2/02, 27/02, 6/04 and 51/07) shall apply to the National Monument.
II
The
Government of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina (hereinafter: the
Government of the Federation) shall be responsible for providing the legal,
scientific, technical, administrative and financial measures necessary for the
protection, conservation and presentation of the National Monument.
The
Commission to Preserve National Monuments (hereinafter: the Commission) shall
determine the technical requirements and secure the funds for preparing and
setting up signboards with basic details of the monument and the Decision to
proclaim the property a National Monument.
III
To ensure
the on-going protection of the National Monument, the following protection
measures are hereby stipulated:
Protection
Level I pertains to the area designed as c.p. 331, c.m. Kovačevo Selo.
The following protection measures shall apply in this area:
-
the church of the
Ascension shall be conserved and restored, and missing parts shall be
reconstructed in their original form, of the same size, using the same or the
same type of materials and building methods wherever possible, based on
documentation on their original form, with the approval of the the Federal
Ministry responsible for regional planning and under the expert supervision of
the heritage protection authority of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The rehabilitation project shall provide for the methods of conservation,
reconstruction, restoration, structural repair and consolidation to be used;
-
to ensure the protection
of the church and to secure the conditions for its rehabilitation, the
following urgent measures are hereby prescribed to prevent the further
deterioration of the building:
-
the protection of the
church from the elements, in particular the roof, the junctions of the walls
with the tower, and the windows,
-
the identification,
classification and proper protection of the fragments of the church remaining
on the site since its destruction,
-
an examination and
structural analysis of the walls and structure,
-
a detailed architectural
survey of the building to document and analyze the structure, materials and
building methods used, as the necessary basis for drawing up a rehabilitation
project;
-
the following protection
measures are hereby stipulated for the surviving frescoes:
-
the conservation and
restoration of the surviving frescoes and parts of frescoes,
-
the future painting of the
church shall correspond to the existing iconographic formula.
Protection Level II shall apply to the areas
designated as
1) c.p. no. 329 (new survey),
c.m. Kovačevo Selo. The following protection measures shall apply in this area:
-
all works are prohibited
other than conservation and restoration works and routine maintenance works on
the old school building;
-
no new burials shall be
carried out at a distance of less than five metres from the existing graves in
the burial ground;
2) part of c.p. no. 332, c.m.
Kovačevo Selo. In this area:
-
the felling of the old oak
tree is prohibited. Only necessary maintenance and essential tree surgery shall
be permitted.
IV
All
executive and area development planning acts not in accordance with the
provisions of this Decision are hereby revoked.
V
Everyone,
and in particular the competent authorities of the Federation of Bosnia and
Herzegovina, the Canton, and urban and municipal authorities, shall refrain
from any action that might damage the National Monument or jeopardize the
preservation thereof.
VI
The
Government of the Federation, the Federal Ministry responsible for regional
planning, the Federation heritage protection authority, and the Municipal
Authorities in charge of urban planning and land registry affairs, shall be
notified of this Decision in order to carry out the measures stipulated in
Articles II to V of this Decision, and the Authorized Municipal Court shall be
notified for the purposes of registration in the Land Register.
VII
The
elucidation and accompanying documentation form an integral part of this
Decision, which may be viewed by interested parties on the premises or by
accessing the website of the Commission (http://www.aneks8komisija.com.ba)
VIII
Pursuant
to Art. V para 4 Annex 8 of the General Framework Agreement for Peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina,
decisions of the Commission are final.
IX
This
Decision shall enter into force on the day following its publication in the
Official Gazette of BiH.
This
Decision has been adopted by the following members of the Commission: Zeynep
Ahunbay, Martin Cherry, Amra Hadžimuhamedović, Dubravko Lovrenović, Ljiljana
Ševo and Tina Wik.
No: 06.1-2-40/2009-35
13 May 2009
Sarajevo
Chair of
the Commission
Amra
Hadžimuhamedović
E l u c i
d a t i o n
I – INTRODUCTION
Pursuant
to Article 2, paragraph 1 of the Law on the Implementation of the Decisions of
the Commission to Preserve National Monuments, established pursuant to Annex 8
of the General Framework Agreement for Peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina, a
“National Monument” is an item of public property proclaimed by the Commission
to Preserve National Monuments to be a National Monument pursuant to Articles V
and VI of Annex 8 of the General Framework Agreement for Peace in Bosnia and
Herzegovina and property entered on the Provisional List of National Monuments
of Bosnia and Herzegovina (Official Gazette of BiH no. 33/02) until the
Commission reaches a final decision on its status, as to which there is no time
limit and regardless of whether a petition for the property in question has
been submitted or not.
On 3 March
2008 the Serbian Orthodox Parish of Tuzla submitted a proposal/petition to the
Commission to Preserve National Monuments to designate the church of the
Ascension in Požarnica as a national
monument of Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Pursuant
to the provisions of the Law, the Commission proceeded to carry out the
procedure for reaching a final decision to designate the Property as a National
Monument, pursuant to Article V para. 4 of Annex 8 and Article 35 of the Rules
of Procedure of the Commission to Preserve National Monuments.
Statement of Significance
Though
badly damaged during the 1992-1995 war and partly restored since then, the
church of the Ascension, built in 1896, has largely retained its original
fabric, and provides important surviving evidence of the iconography and style
of mural painting in the Orthodox churches of the late 19th century. Few
Orthodox churches dating from the Austro-Hungarian period in Bosnia and Herzegovina are
decorated with murals. The church occupies a prominent position in the Kovačica
and Jošanica river valley, and is of great historical and traditional
significance for the identity of the local community and parish. The roof of
the nave, which is original, is of unusual design, with an arched, plastered
ceiling creating the impression of a vault, concealing a double-truss system.
II – PROCEDURE PRIOR TO DECISION
In the
procedure preceding the adoption of a final decision to proclaim the property a
national monument, the following documentation was inspected:
-
Data on the current
condition and use of the property, including a description and photographs,
details of war damage, details of restoration and other works on the property,
etc.
-
Historical, architectural
and other documentary material on the property, as set out in the bibliography
forming part of this Decision.
The
findings based on the review of the above documentation and the condition of
the property are as follows:
1. Details of the property
Location
The village of Požarnica
is on the slopes of Mt. Majevica, about 8 km to the east of Tuzla,
on the main Tuzla
to Bijeljina road, at the confluence of the rivers Kovačica and Jošanica.
The
natural and architectural ensemble of the Orthodox church of the Ascension with
its murals, the remains of the old school building, the burial ground and an
old oak tree, is located on a site designated as cadastral plot nos. 329, 330,
331 and 332 (new survey), municipality Kovačevo Selo, Municipality Tuzla,
Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bosnia and Herzegovina, and is the
property of the Serbian Orthodox Church, Tuzla parish.
Historical information
The
reforms introduced in the Ottoman Empire in the mid 19th century made it easier
for the Christians of Tuzla to obtain a permit (imperial firman) to build
churches (the Tanzimat period – the 1839 Hatt-i Şerif of Gülhane prescribing
equality for all faiths and freedom of religion in Turkey, and the 1856 Hatt-i
Hümayun, the new constitutional law for the Bosnian vilayet, the provisions of
which including granting the Christian church in Turkey the protection of
international law).
The
episcopal see was transferred from Zvornik to Tuzla at the same time as was the
seat of the Zvornik kajmekam(1), and the
eparchy was renamed the eparchy of Zvornik and Tuzla(2).
The
church of the Ascension in Požarnica was built in 1896, and consecrated on 26
October 1896 by Metropolitan Nikolaj (Mandić)(3).
A
tombstone in the far north-eastern corner of the plot designated as c.p. no.
330, c.m. Kovačevo Selo, bears the carved epitaph:
“ОВДЕ
ПОЧИВА Here
lies
СТЕВАН ОТИЋ Stevan
Otić
ЗИДАР Mason
РОЂ. 1886 Г. ПОГИНУО Born 1886, killed
КОД ГРАДЊЕ ТОРЊА while building the tower
1910.
ГОД. in
1910.
СПОМЕНИК ДИГОШЕ This tombstone was erected
ДРУГОВИ.” by his colleagues.
When the
church in Požarnica was dynamited in 1994, the church tower, choir gallery,
iconostasis and apse of the church were destroyed, and the church plate,
liturgical items, registers, archives and documents were removed and destroyed.
St Sava's
hall and the parish hall (both on c.p. no. 332, c.m. Kovačevo Selo) were
destroyed at the same time.
There is
no reliable information on the date when the church tower was built, but the
inscription on the tombstone suggests that it was built 14 years later than the
church.
2. Description of the property
In terms
of layout, the church in Požarnica belongs to the type of single-nave church
with a parvis, nave and altar area, and a gallery leading to the staircase in
the church tower.
The
church lies with its long axis east-west, with the apse at the east end and the
entrance at the west end. It measures 11.70 m wide x 26 m long on the outside(4). The side bearing walls are 80
cm thick and the end walls approx. 60 cm thick; they are built of solid fired
brick, plastered inside and out, as are the walls of the church tower.
The tower
is rectangular in plan, with sides of 2.80 and 3.70 m. The walls of the tower
are approx. 40 cm thick. Inside, where there is a wooden staircase, the tower
measures approx. 2.00 x 2.90 m. The tower has three stages and is topped by a
dome on an octagonal drum; it measures approx. 26.80 m in overall height from
ground level to the top of the dome. The first and second stages of the bell
tower each have three windows, and the third has four; the drum has a window on
each of its eight sides. All the windows on the tower are round-arched. The
present tower was built in 2006-2007.
An arched
passageway through the ground floor of the tower leads to the main entrance
to the church, a round-arched portal measuring approx. 190 x 385 cm, at the
west end of the church. There is also a side door midway along the south wall
of the church.
Within an
area measuring approx. 3.45 x 2.40 m on the inside formed by brick partition
walls approx. 20 cm wide in the north-west corner of the church is a
triple-flight staircase leading to the choir gallery, the floor of which
was approx. 4.50 m above the floor of the parvis. The steps measured approx. 20
x 30 cm, and judging from their position and the way they were attached to the
wall (the sockets for the beams still survive in the wall), were made of wood.
The
corresponding area measuring approx. 3.45 x 2.40 m on the inside formed by
brick partition walls approx. 20 cm wide in the south-west corner of the church
was used for lighting candles(5).
Sockets
in the west perimeter wall of the church at regular intervals of about 1 metre
and at a height of approx. 4.30 m suggest that the bearing structure of the
choir gallery consisted of wooden joists approx. 20 x 20 cm with a length of
approx. 3.75 m, slotted into the wall on the west side and resting on a steel
NP I girder on the east side.
The steel
girder rested on two half-pillars of solid brick, approx. 30 x 50 cm in
section, on the side walls of the church, and on two bearing pillars of solid
brick, approx. 65 x 50 cm in section, set approx. 430 cm apart and each approx.
190 cm from the half-pillars.
The kind
of brick products used to build the infill walls (brick products of various
types and sizes), which differ from those used in the bearing pillars of the
choir gallery, as well as the type of junction between the partition wall and
the pillars, without bonding the bricks together(6), strongly suggest that the partition walls around the staircase
and the candle-lighting area were a later addition.
The
change of level effected by a stone step(7) on the floor of the church, about 6.85 m ease of the face of the
west perimeter wall, which is approx. 2.90 m east of the face of the bearing
pillars of the choir gallery, define the end of the parvis and beginning
of the nave. A solea occupies the full width of the church and a depth
of approx. 2.90 m as measured from the iconostasis or apsidal niche. The solea
is 0.145 m above the level of the nave floor. Within the church, propped
against the north wall, are the stone framents of the ambon that probably
occupied the centre of the solea, in the axis of the royal doors of the
iconostasis.
The iconostasis
and apse were completely destroyed when the church was blown up. The outline
of the iconostasis where it abutted against the walls suggest that it was
located between the continuations of the east perimeter wall, and measured
approx. 5.60 m wide x 4.70 cm high.
The east
wall had a round-arched opening of approx. 500 cm wide and 760 cm high, with
the arch radius of approx. 2.50 m. The heel of the arch was at a height of
approx. 4.70 m above the floor of the solea.
The
apsidal niche is approx. 710 cm wide and 420 cm deep on the inside, with its
longer sides, forming the polygonal apse, from north to south respectively 222
cm, 277 cm, 300 cm, 280 cm and 225 cm in length. The outside walls of the apse
are approx. 25 cm thick, and are of brick blocks, with the parapet of the wall,
which is approx. 80 cm high, of concrete. At the junctions of the sections of
the apse wall are vertical reinforced concrete ring beams, also featuring at
the junction of the apse with the east perimeter wall of the church; above the
apse windows(8) and on
the crown of the apse wall are horizontal ring-beams at a height of approx.
6.45 m above the apse floor. At the same level of 6.45 m, above the apse arch,
level with the junction between the apse and the east wall of the church
(abutting onto the east wall), is a broken reinforced concrete ring beam linking
the apse walls from north to south. The north-east and south-east apse walls
each have a central round-arched window measuring 82 x 280 cm with a parapet of
approx. 180 cm.
The
original wall of the destroyed apse was approx. 65 cm thick, and was of solid
brick. When inspected on 8 April 2009, traces of the junction block between the
old apse wall of solid brick and the east wall of the church could be seen on
the east façade. The top of the former apse wall was about 120-130 cm higher
than the present level, and the apex of the apse roof was about 70 cm higher
than now. Above the apse is a wooden roof frame clad with sheet copper. The
present apse was built in 2006-2007.
The roof
over the rectangular body of the church is gabled, with bearing timbers consisting
of an interesting system of transverse wooden trusses formed by a combination
of queen posts (14 x 14 cm timbers) resting on 12 x 18 cm struts, simple
hanging posts and fixed wooden queen trusses. The roof framing consists of 16 x
20 cm beams.
The roof
cladding consists of galvanized iron laid on one-inch roof boards attached to
the 12 x 16 cm rafters.
The
design of the ceiling is also of interest. The curve of a quarter barrel vault
rises from the side walls of the church at a height of approx. 9.00 m above
floor level and with a width of about 150 cm along the side walls, gradually
merging into the flat surface of the central ceiling, measuring 6.90 x 17.60 m,
at a height of approx. 10.50 m.
Up to a
level of approx. 9.00 m, the side walls are approx. 80 cm thick, but the top
150 cm or so is thinner, at approx. 60 cm. The roof trusses rest on the crown
of the side walls at a height of approx. 10.50 m. Below each roof truss are
short upright wooden posts set on the inside of the crown of the walls, to
which wooden centring in the form of a quarter circle are attached. The ceiling
consists of a lining of 10-12 cm wide wooden boards attached to the centring
and the tie beams in the central section of the underside of the ceiling, to
which in turn reeds were nailed to form a base for the final plaster finish.
The
floors of the parvis, the nave and the altar area were finished with hexagonal
2 cm thick clinker tiles with sides of approx. 21 cm; the gallery has a wooden
floor.
The windows,
with openings of 1.65 x 4.45 m and a parapet of 350 cm, through which light
enters the church, are round-arched, and all have a splay towards the interior
to increase the amount of light entering. The north and south walls each have
three windows.
The façade
of the church is articulated by pilaster strips of approx. 10 x 110 cm(9), set approx. 4.75 m apart and
terminating below the roof cornice in striking arcaded friezes, a feature of
Rascian architecture. The area between the pilaster strips is about 4.75 m
long, and the frieze consists of eight linked arcades about 10 cm deep, 50 cm
wide and 100 cm high, with the apex of the arcades about 30 cm from the edge of
the roof cornice, giving a total height of the arcaded frieze from the foot of
the arcade to the roof cornice of approx. 130 cm.
The
façades of the church tower are articulated by shallow moulded string courses
marking each of the stages of the tower, and where the topmost stage of the
tower passes from a square to a rectangular plan below the drum, as well as the
cornice of the dome.
Description of the murals
The
murals and furnishings of the church of the Ascension in Požarnica were badly
damaged during the 1992-1995 war. When the church was dynamited, much of the
murals were blown off the walls. The surviving frescoes, exposed to the
elements and left without maintenance, are in very poor condition. The
surviving area of the murals on the walls measures 230 x 180 cm, with another
300 x 140 cm on the wall between the parvis and the nave. The murals were
painted in tempera.
Though
badly damaged, five murals have survived on the wall separating the apse from
the nave. The span of the arch is accentuated by an inscription in Cyrillic: СВAТЪ,
СВAТЪ, СВAТЪ, ГОСПОДЪ САВАШДЪ.
The
middle of the wall is occupied by a circular mural with eucharistic motifs and
the Eye of God. Three vertical bands each with one motif appear to float in the
composition, with the Eye of God at the top of the middle band, in a triangle,
combining two meanings: the Eye of God symbolizes God's all-seeing
omnipresence, and the equilateral triangle denotes the Trinity, with its three
components forming a single entity – the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit
forming the one divine nature(10). Below
is a painted cross with IC/XC/NI/KA inscribed above the arms, denoting Jesus
Christ Victorious (Ιēsoũs Khristōs Nika). The golden chalice from which the
wine that is the blood of Christ is at the very bottom of the composition. The
right-hand vertical depicts a vine with ripe fruits, symbolizing the renewal of
the covenant between God and his people, between the Old and the New Testament
– first with Moses, in the Old Testament, and then with Jesus Christ, in the
New. To the left and three ears of wheat, the symbol of abundance and
prosperity, as well as of the bread of the Eucharist, the body of Christ.
On either
side, beside the arch, are two arched frescoes, with the figures of archangels
at the top – Gabriel to the left, and Michael to the right.
The
composition with the Archangel Gabriel creates an impression of ease and
lightness on account of the white clouds on which the archangel is descending
to announce the birth of Jesus to the Virgin. The archangel is portrayed in
profile, left hand raised aloft to announce the birth of the Son of God, and
holding a spray of white lilies (symbol of the Virgin's purity) in his right
hand. Though the church dates from the end of the 19th century, the artist has
harked back to the mediaeval tradition in his treatment of the figure of the
Archangel Gabriel, particularly in the flat halo, typical of Romanesque art,
and the full, sharply-delineated folds of the drapery (a feature of Gothic
art).
All that
survives of the right-hand mural is the top part. However, the garments
(military armour, boots and a red cloak) and the surviving detail of the right
hand holding a flaming sword aloft, suggest that it portrays the Archangel
Michael, captain of the heavenly host.
To the
right on the lower part of the wall is a fresco with the figure of St Sava,
Archbishop of Serbia. The fine figure of the saint occupies the foreground in
close-up, in a plain setting. The treatment of the background, with the pinkish
soil and blue sky, is also intended to denote the importance of the figure
portrayed. This relationship between the figure of the saint and the background
dictated the concentration on the dynamic figure of the saint (his crown, head,
garments etc.), against the static background. The treatment of the light, the
source of which is in the top left-hand corner, falling as if hesitantly on the
drapes and behind the figure of St Sava, suggests the temporal nature of the
composition, caught in a moment of transience, for the shadow will move in the
very next instant. The masculine face of St Sava is painted with meticulous
care. The beard and the long, wavy, shoulder-length hair accentuate the saint's
clear blue eyes and narrow nose. His elaborate vestments, consisting of a long
pink robe and white below-the-knee(11) half conceal his hands, with their long, elegant fingers, and
reveal only the tips of his shoes. St Sava is holding a cross aloft in his
right hand and an open book with a text in his left. Only a few letters have
survived, making it impossible to identify the text.
Opposite
this composition, on the left, is a painting of a female saint (martyr?). The
surface layer of the composition is badly damaged – the painted decoration has
fallen away to the left of the saint – and the part of the wall where the
saint's face would have been has caved in, making it impossible to identify her
with certainty. The simple space without any details, a scene of nature or an
interior, is dominated by the figure of the saint in the middle of the
composition, in close-up. The figure of the middle-aged woman is completely
concealed by the long black robe, falling in monotone folds from head to toe. The
saint is clasping a model of a church in her left hand and holding a long cross
aloft in her right.
The south
wall has four frescoes between the windows from the apse to the entrance.
The
composition with the figure of St John the Baptist portrays him as an ascetic,
a heavy sheepskin covering his emaciated body. Unusually, he is portrayed
wearing sandals instead of barefoot. His left foot is advancing slightly
towards the observer, accentuating the parched soil underfoot. The composition
is in wide frame, but instead of the usual desert scene, the background is
dominated by a green landscape. In the middle ground, to the left of the saint,
is a tree-stump with an axe lodged in it, symbolizing St
John the Baptist and his preaching in the wilderness of Judaea. “And now also the axe is laid unto the roof of
the trees; therefore every tree which bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn
down, and cast into the fire.” (Mt. 3:10 and Lk 3:9) Like the Archangel
Gabriel, his right hand is raised aloft, forefinger pointing, announcing the
coming of the Messiah. This is corroborated by the inscription on the scroll
attached to the arms of the long cross the Baptist is holding in his left hand:
ПОКАЈТЕСЕ/ЈЕР СЕ/ ПРИБЛИЖИ/ЦАРСТВО/НЕБЕСКО [“Repent ye, for the Kingdom of Heaven is at hand.” Mt. 3:2.]
The composition with Prince Lazar
is on two planes. The foreground portrays the saint as an elderly but manly
figure with a luxuriant grey beard and hair. The pallor of his face is
countered by the gold halo and imperial crown set with numerous precious
stones. The movement of his arm to the space below the imperial purple cloak
hanging on the door reveals a long blue robe. The vertical gold band and border
of the robe are decorated with circles with inscribed crosses. The background
is indicated by a dark room from which a curtain falls in thin folds to the
base of the composition. The shadows in the composition, arrayed evenly around
the figure of the saint, suggest that the light comes from where the observer
is standing.
The care
with which it is painted and the harmonious proportions of the composition with
the figure of St Stefan of Dečani render it an exceptionally fine example of
the art of the mural. The composition is in broad plan, depicting an interior
with accurate proportions. The harmony between the spatial plans and the figure
of the saint adds to the clarity of the composition, the symmetry of which is
dictated by the vertical band on the royal robe, composed of green tear-drops
on a gold ground. To the left, on a table covered by a long white table cloth,
a model of the Dečani monastery where St Stefan was buried after dying a
martyr's death cuts across the plane. St Stefan's left arm is leaning on the
table, holding a long cross, as his right forefinger points to the model of
Dečani. The slight displacement of the left foot suggests movement, also
indicated by the folds on the royal robe. His garments are treated with
particular care. The saint's serious face emerges from his wavy grey hair and
beard, and his head is crowned by a gold halo and an elaborate royal crown.
One third
of the composition of St George slaying the dragon has survived. The foreground
begins in the bottom left corner with the dragon, jaws agape. Already
vanquished, the helpless beast is lying on the ground, its bat-like wings
outspread. The end of the battle between the dragon and the saint is
accentuated by the tip of the spear, pointing upwards. St George's powerful body, wearing armour and
a chlamys, is trampling the body of the beast. The Renaissance-style
perspective reveals a palace in the background, to the right of St George, and
a scene of nature with trees.
There are
another four compositions on the north wall. The first mural, by the wall
separating the apse from the nave, features a saint or ecclesiastical
dignitary; in the absence of an inscription it is hard to identify who this may
be. In the middle are St Basil of Ostrog and St Ignatius Theophorus, the
God-bearer. The damage to the saint's face and the inscription above the last
fresco make it impossible to identify.
The
composition with the figure of St Nicholas of Myra is in close-up with a
landscape. The harsh, featureless landscape with a lowering pale blue sky only
sketchily indicates the background of the composition. The middle ground,
however, consists of a horizontal band consisting of the sea and a church with
two blue bell towers (left). To the right, a cruciform, masted boat is sailing
the clear blue sea. Turning towards the observer with slow, measured step, the
figure of the saint occupies the foreground of the composition. The meaning of
the figure is supplemented by the many details of his ecclesiastical vestments,
particularly the purple robe decorated with gold flowers, and the blue
medallion on his chest, his bishop's crozier with the volutes turned to the
cross in the middle, the crown, and so on. To the left, a white handkerchief
with a gold border, depicting a shepherd between two angels, hangs from the
figure's garments.
The scene
in which St Basil of Ostrog is portrayed is simplified to the utmost. The
stern, serious figure of the saint occupies the full height of the centre,
creating the balance of the composition and enhanced by the absolute stillness
revealed by the position of the feet. There is further symmetry in the
modelling of the saint's figure around a vertical line from the cross on the
crown and the large blue precious stone below it, through the strongly-marked
straight line of the nose to the chain with a blue medallion. The saint is
wearing elaborate gold robes with a regular pattern of small red and blue
squares. Heis holding a book in his left hand and giving a blessing with his
right.
In the
composition with St Ignatius Theophorus, the artist has played with light and
shadow. Light shines on the figure of the saint, creating shadows on the face,
robes and background of the composition. The way the shadows lie suggests that
the source of light is from the top left-hand corer. As in the previous
composition, the figure of the saint dominates the foreground, wearing
elaborate garments consisting of a long pink robe and a turquoise cloak with a
gold border. His serious face, with an expression of concentration, is framed
in a gold halo and crown. The long, elegant fingers of the right hand are
arranged in the gesture of benediction(12), and his left hand is holding an icon with the figure of Jesus
Christ. This iconography is the result of the tradition that when Jesus was
preaching about the Kingdom
of Heaven, he called the
young Ignatius over and told the assembled crowd: “Verily I say unto you,
Except ye be converted, and become as little children, ye shall not enter the
kingdom of heaven... Whoso shall receive one such little child in my name
receiveth me.” (Mt. 18:3-5). St Ignatius received the epithet Theophorus for
two reasons: first, because he was carried in Jesus' arms, and second because
he bore the name of God in his heart and on his lips.
The
figure of the saint on the fourth composition has been completely destroyed. He
was wearing a long yellow robe with a red cloak over it, and holding a closed
book.
To the
very east, in the ceiling of the name, two murals with the Evangelists St John
and St Matthew have survived.
The
collapse of the roof structure destroyed much of the mural of St John. The darkness of the background,
painted brown, sets off the brilliant white cloud on which the evangelist is
seated, descending with the forefinger of his right hand raised. He was
probably holding a scroll with a text from his gospel in his left hand. His
attribute, the eagle, is depicted in the middle of the left-hand side of the
composition.
The
middle of the composition of St Matthew has been lost with the collapse of the
roof structure at that point, taking part of the mural with it. Yellow and red
drapery alternate in folds, accentuating the volume of the evangelist, who is
portrayed seated on the white cloud that dominates the composition. To the
right, a youthful angel is peering from the cloud, studying the text on the
sheet held by the apostle: КЊИГА/РОДСТВА/ИСУСА/ХРИСТА/CИНА [The lineage of
Jesus Christ the Son].
These two
murals and the condition of the surviving roof frame with the remains of
painted decoration are sufficient to allow for its reconstruction: it is very
likely that the western part, over the entrance, bore figures of the
Evangelists St Mark and St Luke.
The
figures of St Paraskeva (right) and St Nedelja the Great Martyr (left) are
painted on the entrance wall in the narthex.
When
modelling the composition with St Paraskeva, the artist used various colours to
differentiate the various areas: brown for the foreground, green for the middle
ground, and blue for the background. This chromatic contrast was countered by
the predominant black of the saint's garments, dominating the foreground.
Unlike
this composition, with its faithful depiction of a landscape, the area in which
the figure of St Nedelja the Great Martyr is portrayed consists of the
interaction of the horizontal line of the soil, in pink, and the vertical, in
green. This interplay of horizontal and vertical is complemented by the
chromatic harmony between the saint's long red cloak, tied at the neck, and the
green robe beneath it.
The walls
separating the parvis (narthex) from the nave are decorated with two murals of
rectangular format.
Two male
figures are stepping towards the observer from the leafy landscape in the
background of the composition. Although the inscription over their heads has
been completely destroyed, it seems likely that they are the brothers SS Cyril
and Methodius. They are portrayed in the identical stance, right hand holding a
cross aloft and left hand below the breast, but are distinguished by their
different garments and characterization of the face. The face of the older
brother is framed by thin, precisely modelled eyebrows, a thick beard and his
hair. His lean body is accentuated by a long red robe with a yellow cloak over
it. The younger brother is turning almost imperceptibly towards the older. Large
blue eyes dominate his youthful face, and his unruly brown hair and golden halo
echo the lines of the face. His garments, resembling his brother's, consist of
a long green robe and blue cloak.
All that
survives is the lower part (1/8 of the fresco) on the left hand side, with two
pairs of feet.
The ruins
of the old school building, measuring approx. 11 x 13.50 m, are in the
northernmost part of the churchyard, about 20 m north of the church, on plot
no. c.p. 329, c.m. Kovačevo Selo. The school was built in 1874, but had not
been in use since the end of World War II. The ground floor survived, built of
hewn and rubble stone. Over the years certain interventions had been carried
out by building on in brick and, on the south wall, concrete. The remains of
the building are overgrown with rank vegetation.
About 24
m west of the church, on plot no. c.p. 322, c.m. Kovačevo Selo, is the St Sava
hall, destroyed in 1994 and rebuilt in 2003. It has a footprint of 7.05 x 15.60
m, and consists of a basement and ground floor, with a gabled roof. The
building is not subject to the protection measures prescribed by this Decision.
About 20
m south-west of the church, on plot no. c.p. 332, c.m. Kovačevo Selo, the
parish hall was built in 1975, destroyed in 1994 and rebuilt in 2008. It has a
footprint of aprox. 9.90 x 10.20 m, and consists of a ground and first floor,
with a gabled roof.
About 70
m south of the church, on plot no. c.p. 332, c.m. Kovačevo Selo, is an ancient
oak tree, with a circumference at chest height of about 505 cm, and a crown of
about 25 metres in width.
About 30
m north-east of the church, on plot no. c.p. 330, c.m. Kovačevo Selo, is a
group of about ten graves. The oldest tombstones date from the early 20th
century, and some of the graves are the last resting place of victims of
Fascist terror in World War II.
3. Research and conservation and
restoration works
There is
no available information concerning any conservation or restoration works.
4. Current condition of the
property
The
building was devastated in 1994 when explosive devices were planted inside the
church, one by the tower and the other in the apse. Part of the devastation has
been described in Section 2, Description of the property. The roof is in very
poor condition and leaking badly. The ceiling and roof timbers were largely
destroyed or badly damaged. The choir gallery was completely destroyed, as was
the staircase. The gable wall of the building at the junction with the tower no
longer exists, nor does the part of the roof over this junction, making this
currently the most vulnerable part of the building. All the window frames have
been devastated, with the grid panels and glazing destroyed.
There are
cracks in the east perimeter wall around the apse.
The
interior of the building has been largely destroyed, and the plaster has
cracked or fallen away entirely from the inside walls. The floors have also
been destroyed. None of the church furnishings remain, all having been
completely destroyed.
Current condition of the
surviving murals
The
surviving murals are in very poor condition.
5. Legal status to date
According
to the Institute for the Protection of Monuments of the Federal Ministry of
Culture and Sport, the church of the Ascension in Požarnica, Tuzla, was neither listed nor protected by
the Institute for the Protection of the Cultural, Historical and Natural
Heritage of BiH(13).
6. Specific risks
Given the
shortcomings of the reconstruction works on the apse and tower, it is feared
that the remains of the wall paintings may be destroyed during continued repair
works on the interior of the church. The rehabilitation works to date have been
carried out without suitable project documentation and without any prior
conservation and restoration examinations and guidelines.
If the
works covered by the cost estimate for repair works on the church of the
Ascension in Požarnica, drawn up in 2007-2008 by Gars of Crno Blato, Tuzla, were to be carried
out, they would constitute a specific risk to the church. The cost estimate is
not part of an appropriate rehabilitation project, which must be based on the
findings of surveys and examinations of the building, a valorization, and
conservation-restoration and investigative guidelines (see Clause III of the
enacting clauses of this Decision)(14).
III – CONCLUSION
Applying
the Criteria for the adoption of a decision on proclaiming an item of property
a national monument (Official Gazette of BiH nos. 33/02 and 15/03), the
Commission has enacted the Decision cited above.
The
Decision was based on the following criteria:
For the church
A. Time frame
B. Historical value
E. Symbolic value
E.i. ontological value
E.ii. religious value
E.iii. traditional value
E.iv. relation to rituals or ceremonies
E.v. significance for the identity of a group of
people
F. Townscape/landscape value
F.i. relation to other elements of the site
F.ii. meaning in the townscape
G. Authenticity
G.iii. use and function
G.vi. spirit and feeling
G.vii. other internal and external factors
The
following documents form an integral part of this Decision:
-
Copy of cadastral plan,
scale 1:2500, c.p. nos. 329, 330, 331 and 332 (new survey), c.m. Kovačevo Selo,
Municipality Tuzla, Plan no. 4, issued on 19 May 2008 by the Department of
Geodetics and Proprietary Affairs, Municipality Tuzla, Tuzla Canton, Federation
of Bosnia and Herzegovina;
-
Identification of plot no.
c.p. 331, c.m. Kovačevo Selo (new survey), corresponding to c.p. no. 1096/2,
c.m. Požarnica; issued on 19 May 2008 by the Department of Geodetics and Proprietary
Affairs, Municipality Tuzla, Tuzla Canton, Federation of Bosnia and
Herzegovina;
-
Excerpt from title deed
no. 176 (for c.p. no. 331, property of the Serbian Orthodox Parish of Tuzla),
c.m. Kovačevo Selo, issued on 19 May 2008 by the Department of Geodetics and
Proprietary Affairs, Municipality Tuzla, Tuzla Canton, Federation of Bosnia and
Herzegovina;
-
Land Register entry no.
378, plot no. 1096/2, issued by the Land Register office of the Municipal Court
in Tuzla on 21
May 2008;
-
Photographic documentation:
-
Photographs of the natural
and architectural ensemble of the Orthodox church of the Ascension in Požarnica
with its old oak tree, taken on 8 and 22 April 2009 by art historian Aleksandra
Bunčić and architect Emir Softić using Canon PowerShot S3IS and Canon PowerShot
A450 digital cameras.
Bibliography
During
the procedure to designate the natural and architectural ensemble of the church
of the Ascension in Požarnica with its old oak tree as a national monument of Bosnia
and Herzegovina the following works were
consulted:
1977 Srpska pravoslavna eparhija zvorničko-tuzlanska, Šematizam
(Serbian Orthodox Eparchy of Zvornik and Tuzla,
Schematism). Tuzla:
1977
1984 Brkić, Nemanja. Tehnologija slikarstva, vajarstva i
ikonografija (The Techniques of Painting, Sculpture and Iconography). Belgrade: University
of Art, 1984
2005 Jovanović, Zoran M. Azbučnik pravoslavne ikonografije i
graditeljstva (ABC of Orthodox Iconography and Architecture). Belgrade: Museum of the
Serbian Orthodox Church, Dina, 2005
2006 Badurina, Anđelko (ed.). Leksikon ikonografije, liturgike i
simbolike zapadnog kršćanstva (Lexicon of the Iconography, Liturgy and Symbolism
of Western Christianity). Zagreb:
Kršćanska sadašnjost, 2006
2007 Cost estimate for repairs to the church of the Ascension in
Požarnica, carried out in 2007-2008 by Gars of Crno Blato, Tuzla.
Documentation
from the archives of the Serbian Orthodox Church in Tuzla.
(1) A senior
representative of the Ottoman authorities.
(2) The
following is an account of the origins of the original Zvornik eparchy: “At the
time of the Turkish conquest, when the Srebrenik metropolitanate ceased to be,
the area that fell to the Turks probably belonged to the Arilje
metropolitanate, while the area that remained under Hungarian rule became part
of the Srem eparchy. When they fell to
the Turks in the late 15th and early decades of the 16th century, north-eastern
Bosnia
and Mačva became part of the new Zvornik eparchy, which covered the same
territory as the Zvornik sanjak and was based in Zvornik, as was the seat of
the sanjak. The areas between the rivers Bosna, Sava and Spreča and Mt Majevica
were part of the eparchy, along with the whole of the Drina valley on the right
bank of the river Drina, and the Brvenik kadiluk, joined in 1528-1533 by
Mačva.” (Srpska pravoslavna eparhija zvorničko-tuzlanska, Šematizam, Tuzla:
1977, 19)
(3) Srpska
pravoslavna eparhija zvorničko-tuzlanska, Šematizam, Tuzla: 1977, 214
(4) 2.80 +18.80
+ 4.45 m (length of the south side of the church tower + length of the
rectangular body of the church + the apse) = 26 metres
(5) The sooty
deposits on the inside of the perimeter walls and the bearing structure of the
ventilators in the grid panel of the outside windows, suggest that this was
what this room was used for.
(6) When the
explosive device that blew up the tower and gallery detonated, the plaster fell
away from the junction of the bearing pillars and the partition walls,
revealing these differences (op. E. Softić).
(7) The rise is
approx. 14.5 cm high and the stone tread is approx. 34 cm wide; the pieces
composing the step are approx. 75-80 cm wide. The front of the step has a
rounded bullnose approx. 6 cm in depth. The floor of the nave is thus approx.
14.5 cm lower than that of the parvis.
(8) At a height
of approx. 4.60 m from the apse floor.
(9) Since the
pilaster strip is 10 cm thick, it makes a not insignificant contribution to
reinforcing the bearing walls, which are 90 cm thick at each pilaster strip (80
cm wall + 10 cm pilaster strip).
(10) Anđelko
Badurina (ed.), Leksikon ikonografije, liturgike i simbolike zapadnog
kršćanstva, Zagreb:
Kršćanska sadašnost, 2006, 605.
(11)
Translator's note: a word is missing here in the original. The fact that the
garment the name of which is missing is white suggests perhaps an alb or
sticharion. The illustration accompanying the text is not clear enough to
assist in identifying the garment in question.
(12) The hand
raised in benediction is depicted with the forefinger straight and the middle
finger slightly bent, denoting IC (Jesus), the forefinger representing the I
and the bent middle finger the C; the thumb and ring finger forming a cross and
the bent little finger represent an X and a C, making XC (Christos). This is
why the Creator, in his divine wisdom, gave us just five fingers, no more and
no fewer but just the number required to denote the name of Christ. Nemanja
Brkić, Tehnologija slikarstva, vajarstva i ikonografija, Belgrade: University
of Art, 1984, 294.
(13) Letter
from the Institute for the Protection of Monuments of the Federal Ministry of
Culture and Sport ref. 07-40-4-1896-1/08 of 21.05.2008 to the Commission to
Preserve National Monuments.
(14) The cost
estimate for repair works on the church of the Ascension in Požarnica, drawn up
in 2007-2008 by Gars of Crno Blato, Tuzla,
provides for:
-
repair works to build the gallery and gable (west) wall of
the church, entailing demolishing the masonry substructure below the choir
gallery, cutting into the wall to install horizontal and vertical reinforced
concrete ring beams, constructing the reinforced concrete ceiling of the choir
gallery, demolishing the damaged gable walls and making new ones of brick laid
in lime cement mortar, and making new foundations for the masonry substructure
of the choir gallery;
-
repairs to the altar area (installing reinforced concrete
reinforcements around the opening in the east perimeter wall; laying
foundations);
-
repairs to the roof (dismantling the roof cladding, roof
timbers and ceiling structure; laying a reinforced concrete perimeter ring
beam; installing a new timber roof frame resting on a primary grid of steel
girders; cladding of sheet metal painted with aluminium paint imitating tiles;
making a new plasterboard ceiling).
|